A worked example
Who has the key when chapter two starts?
“Mara left the brass key in the sugar tin. From the doorway, Eli heard the lid scrape shut.”
Try this fictional mystery opening in a fresh chat. Ask Claude to list what each character could know from those two sentences. Mara knows where the key is. Eli heard metal scrape. Whether he could see the tin from the doorway is a decision the author still gets to make.
Now suppose the next draft opens with “Eli plucked the key from the tin before breakfast.” Read the end of chapter one again. If you want Eli to find the key by sound, give him a moment to earn it. If you want him to keep guessing, leave the key where it is.
Here is one way to earn the discovery. “At breakfast Eli opened the tea caddy first. Mara kept buttering her toast. When his hand reached the sugar tin, her knife stopped.” The reader still remembers the key. Eli gets new evidence. Mara gives away her secret without saying a word.
For your own book, keep three short notes beside each accepted chapter. Record what changed hands, who witnessed it, and what the next scene may reveal. When you return to Claude, ask it to compare the next opening against those notes and quote the sentence that supports each discovery.